A young giraffe named Benito has become the center of a debate regarding his welfare at a park in Ciudad Juarez, Mexico. Arriving from a more temperate climate in Sinaloa just last month, the 3-year-old giraffe is struggling to adapt to the harsh desert conditions.

Animal activists have raised concerns about Benito's small, sparsely treed enclosure, which offers minimal protection from the elements. They've launched a "Save Benito" campaign, advocating for his relocation to a more suitable environment, particularly given the approaching winter season with its snow and freezing temperatures.

The park's limited shade structures provide inadequate shelter from the intense sun, rain, and even hail. While a small winter shed exists, activists argue it's insufficient for the giraffe's needs. Benito's diet is also a concern, as he's nearly depleted the few small trees within his enclosure.

Blue Hills, a Texas sanctuary ranch, has offered to provide Benito with a spacious, heated environment and a proper diet. They emphasize the stark contrast between their 320-acre property with abundant trees and Benito's current limited surroundings.

Park officials, however, defend their care of Benito, citing increased visitor numbers since his arrival. While acknowledging the lack of trees, they highlight ongoing improvements to the enclosure, including a new heated winter house, a larger sun canopy, and a cleaner water source. They maintain that Benito's living conditions are optimal.

Public opinion is divided. Some visitors, like 11-year-old Derek Reyes, express mixed feelings, suggesting that while Benito might survive in the park, a more natural environment with a herd would be preferable.

Benito's situation echoes the experience of Modesto, a previous giraffe at the park who lived there for 21 years before passing away last year. Activists are determined to prevent Benito from suffering the same fate, isolated and exposed to the harsh climate.

Park officials are planning to address some of the concerns by eventually introducing a female giraffe to provide companionship for Benito. However, the core issue of the suitability of the park environment for a giraffe remains a point of contention.

The debate over Benito's well-being highlights the complex considerations involved in keeping exotic animals in environments far from their natural habitats. It raises questions about the balance between providing educational and entertainment opportunities for the public and ensuring the ethical treatment and welfare of the animals.