CNN's Defamation Loss: A Deep Dive into the Zachary Young Case

Created: JANUARY 26, 2025

Former U.S. Navy member Zachary Young emerged victorious in a defamation lawsuit against CNN, a verdict that has sent ripples through the network. An inside source revealed to Fox News Digital that the loss, while perhaps anticipated, has significantly impacted CNN's internal atmosphere.

Young's legal battle stemmed from a 2021 CNN report that insinuated he was involved in illicit activities while aiding Afghan refugees during the U.S. military withdrawal. He contended that the report tarnished his reputation and negatively impacted his business. The jury awarded Young $4 million for lost earnings and $1 million for personal damages, also finding CNN liable for punitive damages before a settlement was reached.

Zachary Young speaks with Fox News Digital

Following the settlement, Young expressed a sense of relief and vindication to Fox News Digital, emphasizing the ordeal's three-year duration.

The case garnered increasing media attention as it progressed, although CNN's internal coverage remained limited. Court documents revealed internal CNN communications that contained disparaging remarks about Young, further fueling the controversy.

Testimony during the trial exposed internal dissent within CNN regarding the report's accuracy. A senior editor expressed concerns about the report's flaws, while another reporter admitted to not fully considering the potential impact on Young. The plaintiff, meanwhile, testified about the emotional toll the report took on his personal life.

CNN reporter Katie Bo Lillis and Navy veteran Zachary Young

While CNN issued a public apology in 2022 for implying Young's involvement in a "black market," several CNN employees testified they disagreed with the network's decision.

A CNN representative stated the network would learn from the case while reaffirming their commitment to robust journalism. An internal source, however, attributed the issues to an overzealous reporter rather than a systemic cultural problem. This incident comes at a time of low morale within CNN, with reports of potential layoffs circulating.

CNN headquarters

Another CNN insider described the revealed private messages as highly damaging. The trial also highlighted the apparent disconnect between CNN's editorial staff and its on-air personalities.

U.S. Navy veteran Zachary Young teared up on the witness stand

Despite the legal victory, Young stated he holds no ill will towards CNN, expressing hope that the network and other media outlets will use this as an opportunity for self-reflection and improvement.

Comments(0)

Top Comments

Comment Form